Two policies at the same monthly price can pay out very differently. Here's what moves a pet insurance premium and how to compare quotes on equal terms.
Shopping elsewhere? Also for: UK
Pet insurance pricing depends heavily on your pet and the policy settings you choose, and identical-looking plans can differ a lot in what they actually cover. This is a general guide to how premiums are set and how to compare quotes fairly - not advice on which policy is right for you. The premium you're quoted reflects your pet's species, breed, age and location, plus the deductible, reimbursement rate and payout limit you select.
| Tier | Typical price | What you're getting |
|---|---|---|
| Accident-only (dog or cat) | $10 - $25 per month | Covers injuries but not illnesses; cheapest tier, suited to owners who only want catastrophic-injury cover. |
| Accident + illness (cat) | $15 - $40 per month | The common comprehensive tier for cats; lower than dogs on average. |
| Accident + illness (dog) | $30 - $70 per month | Higher than cats and climbs with breed and age; large and predisposed breeds cost more. |
| Wellness / routine add-on | $10 - $25 per month extra | Optional rider for vaccines and checkups; effectively prepaying routine care, so weigh against paying out of pocket. |
FindPrices checks the major stores for you, so you start from the lowest total price - not the first sticker you see.
Compare Pricing Now - It's FreeThe fixed factors are your pet's species, breed, age and your location: dogs cost more than cats, large and predisposed breeds cost more than small mixed breeds, older pets cost more than puppies and kittens, and vet-cost differences by region shift the price. You can't change those, but they explain why two owners get very different quotes.
The adjustable factors are the deductible, the reimbursement percentage and the annual payout limit. A higher deductible and lower reimbursement rate cut the premium but raise what you pay at claim time, and vice versa. Two plans at the same monthly price can therefore deliver very different real-world value depending on these settings.
Match the settings before you compare. Quote each insurer at the same deductible, the same reimbursement rate and the same annual limit, or you're comparing a cheap-but-thin plan against a richer one. Marketplaces that price several carriers for the same pet at once make this easier.
Read the exclusions as closely as the price. Pre-existing conditions are universally excluded, and waiting periods, per-condition caps and bilateral-condition clauses vary by insurer and quietly change a policy's value. For guidance specific to your pet, ask your veterinarian or a licensed agent; this page is general pricing information.
Accident-and-illness coverage commonly runs about $15-$40 a month for cats and $30-$70 for dogs, with accident-only plans cheaper and wellness riders adding more. The exact premium depends on your pet's breed and age, your location and the deductible and reimbursement settings you pick.
Dogs tend to have higher and more frequent vet costs, and large or predisposed breeds raise the risk further, so insurers price them above cats. Age and location add to it, which is why quotes vary widely even between two dogs.
A higher deductible and a lower reimbursement percentage lower your monthly premium but increase what you pay when you file a claim, while the reverse raises the premium for more generous payouts. Because of this, two plans at the same price can differ a lot in real value - compare the settings, not just the monthly cost.
Use a comparison marketplace or get quotes directly from several insurers using the same deductible, reimbursement rate and annual limit for your specific pet. Matching the settings is what makes the comparison fair and reveals which carrier prices your pet best.
No - pre-existing conditions are excluded across the industry, which is one reason premiums are lower if you enroll a pet while it's young and healthy. Waiting periods and per-condition caps also vary by insurer, so read the exclusions alongside the price.
FindPrices does the comparison shopping for you, every time - quietly, automatically, on every product page.